Wednesday, February 9, 2011

The Misuse of Crates in Training

One of the things most dog owners will talk about and throw around is 'crate training'.

Crate training is one of those things in dog training, a lot like dominance, that different people talk about a lot, but most of the time they all have very different definitions and meanings.

I'm going to focus this post on what good crate training is, and when crate training turns into doggie prison. I wrote this post because one of the things I'm seeing in my classes and mostly in private consultations is misuse of crates in training. If there's any other trainers reading this I'd be interested to hear if you notice the same trends.

"Crate training" and the use of a crate should have a very limited use in housebreaking your new puppy. First let me say that housebreaking is all about 2 things :
1) A good schedule and
2) good reinforcement

You should know when your puppy needs to go pee - which is first thing in the morning, after any meal or drink, after any play, and after waking up. Puppies generally cannot hold their pee any longer than 1 hour for each month of age. Puppies are pee machines, so every-time you go outside and give puppy a chance, usually they will take it.

When however they don't go after one of the above mentioned times - thats when a crate comes in. You temporarily confine the puppy for a few minutes to ensure he doesn't use the bathroom inside - then after maybe 5 minutes you go outside and try again. Lots of reinforcement going pee in the correct place outside is what makes these confinements less and less necessary.

The crate is also used for when you just don't have the time to watch the new puppy, and your concerned he may get into something, or may go pee in the house. These periods should be brief. Crates can also be used at night when the puppy is sleeping to avoid him choosing any late night pees. Again you will have to get up early because a young puppy cannot hold it for 7 hours a night. This will come later.

If you have to leave puppy for a full day while your at work - don't confine him to a crate. Instead put him in a puppy area - a room in the house where his water bowl, stuffed kongs and food and toys are. Make sure this area also contains a doggie toilet. I recommend using paper with some grass and turf over it to simulate the outside. Remember a young puppy simply cannot hold it for a long time and if your not going to be home, its only fair to give him a toilet. You can also choose to do this at night if you have to, but I prefer waking up early in those first few weeks.

A lot of people will tell you that dogs are 'den' animals and enjoy being in a crate, and that may be true, but if so just leave the crate open. If you dog wants to go in there to chill out - great, but let it be his choice.

The problem I see more and more is the crate becomes a prison - a place where the dog goes whenever there are visitors because he jumps up, or barks, or gets aggressive.

Crates also become a place where the is confined all day because he destroys the house, or barks, or does any other list of unwanted behaviors. Crates become a 'quick fix' for any behavioral issue from separation issues to destructive chewing. While this may 'fix' the problem, your dogs emotional state remains unchanged.

Negative behavior as outlined above is the result of anxiety and other emotional distress. Confinement in a crate will simply make those conditions worse, and likely the dog harder and harder to live with. Your best solution is to contact a qualified trainer to address those issues.

Its my opinion that once your dog is housebroken, there is really no reason for a crate anymore - just be certain to not be asking too much of your dog. If you have to be away from your dog for long periods of time, consider a dog walker, dog daycare, or go home on lunch to ensure your dog gets a chance to get out. No one wants to hold their pee beyond what is comfortable and dogs are no different!

Remember, human babies get to wear diapers and just go bathroom whenever the hell they want - why are dogs just expected to hold it until its convenient for us?

Thursday, January 27, 2011

Yikes its been a while

Ok so I'm not dead! Its been a busy few months and it just seems blogging didn't really factor into my time - but I'm going to try to recommit to keep this up to date.

For all of November and most of December I was recovering from surgery - this prevented me from doing any work with dogs and I just spent most of my time reading. Now I'm back into the swing of things, however I'm never really into the swing of things when it comes to winter. I am very "Bearlike" and wish I could just crawl into a cave and wake up in April :)

Lot of changes for Golden Rule Training. The business was officially registered this month, I've ended my relationship with Petcetera and will be holding classes at a local community centre going forward - and I'll be opening an online store selling quality dog toys from the VIP product line, or "Tuffy" line.

The online store is taking most of my time so I hope to have that online soon - also the Dog Expo is in Halifax next month and I'll be attending that so watch for me there.

In my new post I'm going to talk about housebreaking and crate training. More and more I'm finding more dogs confined to crates during the day. I don't call this 'crate training' I call this doggie prison - and I'll be explaining that more in the next post.

As always email me with any questions!

Monday, October 18, 2010

The Sphere of Influence

The sphere of influence is a term I use when discussing classical conditioning. Classical conditioning as we know pairs a neutral stimulus with a conditioned stimulus so that the neutral stimulus takes on meaning for the animal.

The most popular example is using a clicker followed by a presentation of food, so that the animal comes to know that "click" means food. However dogs see the world very different than us, and aspects of their reality are difficult to comprehend as we can never see the world quite as they do.

One thing that is widely proven through science is that dogs discriminate far closer than we do when forming associations. For example a dog that is not socialized to Black men may display fear if approached by one, even if the dog has been well socialized to White men, Asian men, Indian men, etc. A dog may also fail to respond to reward training if he has been conditioned that the reward will only be present if your bait bag is on your belt.

Enter the sphere of influence. When classically conditioning it's critical to be mindful of all the things your influencing. This counts for both positive conditioning but is very important to be aware of if a dog is being trained with punishment (P+).

When we want a dog to feel good about something - we pair it with food or other pleasurable items. However we must be sure we are pairing the right object in the dogs mind.

If I want to cure dog aggression, I am going to give lots of treats whenever other dogs are present - so my aggressive dog replaces the bad feelings about other dogs, with good feelings. I want to counter condition him that dogs = treats and good things with the end mental result to be dogs = good things (and thus not to be attacked).

However the sphere of influence may instead teach him that me wearing my sweater = good things, or my shoes = good things or walking in the neighbourhood = good things and not other dogs. I cannot be sure which condition the dog is focusing on, if at all. In order to get the dog to focus in on other dogs, I need to insure I change the surroundings and conditions to many different situations, while keeping the one constant I want to focus on the same - in this case other dogs.

If I ignored this principle, My dog would likely have good feelings about a number of different things, however I could never be sure how strong that feeling would be, nor to which circumstance it would be directly associated to.

This is specially concerning if punishment is involved. Consider this example:

"The father of the family is very frustrated with the family dog who is always peeing in the house. The fathers ritual when he comes home is to take the keys out of the door, find the dog and slap him for the pee he discovers each day when coming home. The dog is becoming more and more fearful each time the father comes home. One day the mother comes home around the same time the father usually does, and removes the keys from the door and comes inside. The dog attacks and bites the mother putting her in hospital. The dog is euthanized due to his 'unpredictable' attack on someone who never harmed him."

What really happened here? Because the dog was being punished with a regular set of criteria - he was conditioned to a number of factors, and any number of those may have pushed him over the edge. So the dog learned that

a) a certain time of day predicts punishment
b) sound of keys jingling coming out of door predict punishment
c) the father's presence predicts punishment

However it only required condition a and condition b to be present in order to get the reaction from the dog. The mother was an unfortunate victim of the classical conditioning sphere of influence that was taking place each time the dog was punished. The punishment became too much and finally caused the dog to lash out in a preemptive strike towards what he believed would be a punishment based on classical criteria.

Take another example - a dog gets hit by a car. Just before hitting the dog the car honks it's horn. This dog could be scared of cars, a horn sound, the specific area in which the accident happened, or even the weather at the time of the incident from now on. All these items were simultaneously conditioned from this one incident (conditioning happens much faster with a fear emotion).

So in summary - be very mindful of this sphere of influence in both the positive and negative (punishment) applications

Positive - change the other criteria for reward in each situation keeping one constant to focus on the exact object you want to pair.

Punishment - be aware that any dog that has been punished in the past may have associated the impending punishment with any number of critera including your sex, clothing, sounds or location. Just because we know the dog may be in a safe place far away from the punisher - he doesn't make this same safe association that a human would.

Thursday, October 14, 2010

Proud to Be Canadian - Congrats to Richmond, BC

From CTVBC.CA :

B.C. city passes Canada's first puppy sale ban

"The public will now get a chance to weigh in on the decision to ban retail puppy sales in suburban Vancouver, after three readings of the new bylaw were passed unanimously Tuesday night.

City councillors in Richmond, B.C., spent hours hearing from the public and debating the decision. The move, A Canadian first, is intended to curb the purchase of animals from puppy mills and stop people from impulsively buying animals.

Coun. Evelina Halsey-Brandt said a fourth reading, which finalizes the motion into law, will happen within the month. Pet store owners will then have until April 2011 to sell or remove all their puppies.

"People are going to learn that animals have the right to decency to have their health looked after," she told ctvbc.ca. "Now other cities will do the same thing."

Animal rights activists are trumpeting the council's decision, saying pet store puppies aren't awarded the same freedoms as dogs raised by reputable breeders.

"These pets that we're talking about that are shipped to pet stores they don't start out as pets, they're simply livestock," Rae Goodrich of the B.C. SPCA told council.

Marcie Moriarty, general manager of cruelty investigations for the B.C. SPCA, says the new bylaw is the first step in shutting down Canadian puppy mills.

"Any simple business model states that if you take away some of the demand, like these dogs, you'll have an impact on the production," she told ctvbc.ca."

This is great news and hopefully the rest of Canada will follow suit. Puppies belong in loving homes socializing with their mother and litter mates until going home with a family and more socialization can continue. Puppies do NOT belong in clear glass boxes in Pet Stores.

I would submit that many dogs are surrendered to shelters because they were victims of an impulse buyer. Many people are also aware of the poor conditions the puppies live in being stuck in a box all day and feel the need to 'rescue' the dog - an admirable reason, but sadly promotes the problem with the continued sales.

I believe greatly in personal freedoms, but I believe that the government must step in to regulate the care and condition of not only dogs but all animals. Those animals have no choice in how they are treated, and we must ensure that we as a society agree on how they should be treated and people not conforming to those rules held accountable.

There is plenty of money to be made in selling pet products without the need to sell animals. Sadly there are more than enough dogs in shelters that need homes. I always get sad when I see a new litter of puppies up at the SPCA shelter because that means X number of more older dogs that now won't get homes.

I know everyone loves a cute puppy, but please consider an older dog or adult dog if your considering adding a dog to your family. Puppies are a LOT of work, and while any new dog comes with responsibilities - an older dog can usually fit right into a new home without the need for housebreaking, bite training, puppy classes and all the critical socialization that must be done for a new puppy.

I applaud Richmond in taking this step (like most of Europe has already done by the way) in moving Canada into being a leader in companion animal care.

Thursday, September 30, 2010

Is the world coming to an end?

Very strange things afoot in the dog training world. Cesar Millan is coming out with a new book titled "Cesar's Rules" and it seems that the father of positive dog training, Ian Dunbar, is featured in a chapter of it. It seems the book is a compilation of both Cesar and other dog trainers speaking about their methods.

While I believe Cesar has really set dog training back - its very encouraging to think he might be examining his methods, or at the very least using his fame to promote other trainers and methods.

No matter what you think of him, Cesar Millan has huge power because millions of people see him and adore him. Sadly many people take his word as gospel and that affects the lives of a great many dogs all around the world.

If he were to use his fame to promote reward training that would be a treat for trainers and dogs alike.

Here's the link of what Dr Dunbar said regarding working with Cesar:

http://www.dogstardaily.com/blogs/my-contribution-cesar-millans-new-book

Here is the video promo featuring Ian Dunbar and Cesar together

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5z6XR3qJ_qY&feature=youtube_gdata

Tuesday, September 21, 2010

Shock Collars

Shock collars are a big subject in the world of dog training. People who are opposed to them are vehemently (and usually angrily) against them. Those that promote them are very defensive of their stance.

I'm writing this post because I recently saw a Halifax training site, that is very heavily promoted, making use of what they refer to as "E-collars". E-Collars stand for electronic collar, which is a nicer way of saying 'shock' collar.

On this site they had 2-3 videos showing how great E-collars work - and I was really curious to see this. I was curious to see how a site was going to get customers when they are going to post videos of dogs being shocked. Upon watching them though I discovered the real ugly truth about this training method - they actually DON'T want you to see it up front!

One video showed a trainer and dog (a Shepard mix) doing an obedience routine with many sits, downs, lots of eye contact, and various obedience work being done on an agility style pause table. This dog was already trained and thus wasn't shocked once during the video. The premise of the video was to see how great E-collar training can make your dog - but without actually showing the method itself.

The second video showed how great E-collars are for curing aggression. This video showed an out of control dog, lunging and snarling in one clip - then faded to the same dog behaving perfectly and walking calming. Again - no shocks, no method shown, just final product.

The third video showed an 8 year old girl or so 'training' a rottie. Once again it was deceiving because the girl never actually 'trained' the dog - he was clearly trained very well. The little girl proceeded to walk around with the dog at perfect heel position, and give a number of commands. The shock collar was on the dog, and the trainer was filming. I'll mention the importance of this later.

Some people might ask, well I only want a trained dog, I am only interested in the final product, why should I care how a professional gets to the finished product? I don't need to watch my mechanic work on my car, I just want it to work when I pick it up.

Well dog training is very different - cars aren't alive, dogs are. The method used to train your dog is going to have a total effect on his personality, relationship with you and others, and may or may not cause other problems. This same training company says their training methods are 'based in science' however science is quite clear that punishment should be a last resort for training - and must be used extremely carefully to avoid lasting behavioral damage.

Stephen Lindsay in his excellent book "Handbook of applied dog behavior and training vol 1" lists 20 different concerns that you must be aware of when using punishment training. A whole chapter in this very long (420pg) book is devoted to the science of punishment in training and various experiments done on animals throughout the ages on punishment training. He lists well over 40 scientific papers in his review.

His conclusion in this matter: "Punishment should be used only after other positive training options have been carefully considered or exhausted."

Furthermore - the Veterinary Behavior Society of America states: "The AVSAB's position is that punishment is not appropriate as a first-line or early-use treatment for behavior problems. Modification should focus on reinforcing desirable behaviors, removing reinforcement for inappropriate behaviors, and addressing the emotional state and environmental conditions driving undesirable behavior."

The Canadian Veterinary Society states: "Recent years have seen a shift towards reward-based methods, such as clicker training and the use of food, toys and praise as motivators. Animal behaviourists conclude that training techniques that employ punishment rather than rewards-based methods do not improve dog obedience and actually increase problematic dog behaviours.Confrontational methods of training such as the use of physical force, rolling dogs, growling, or staring dogs down may increase the likelihood of aggressive responses in dogs. The use of shock collars is associated with short-term and long-term negative consequences including fear and anxiety.

I go into more detail on why punishment isn't effective on my site - but the biggest problem I see with punishment is a very general one. Dog training is generally done BY the owner - with guidance and direction from the trainer. This means that most training being done on the dog isn't by a professional, but rather the owner.

When I run obedience classes I give homework to my classes - without practice there is no way a group of dogs can learn any behavior reliably in an hour. We discuss success and failure through the 6 week class and work on improvement. I want pet owners who feel like they can communicate and train their dog without always needing a professional trainer.

As with any new skill, people make mistakes. Some people are more skilled and catch on - others take more time and make more errors. When I do clicker training I see people clicking at the wrong time, forgetting to click, giving food at the wrong time, not phasing out food in time - you name it. I have older people that may take extra explanation, and children that are overly eager and excited. We coach and work through the errors and issues to improve everyone's skill.

With clicker and food training - this isn't a big deal. Worse case scenario is the dog takes longer to train and maybe gets a lot of extra food that maybe he didn't really need. A wrong click or a wrong food delivery won't hurt anyone. People also get frustrated and sometimes want to give up but we talk through it.

With punishment however - errors can cause serious psychological damage and aggression. This is specially true if the owner is getting frustrated. This is also not a method that every dog will respond to. I normally see shock collar demonstrations on Shepards and other large, tough breeds - I have yet to see an E-collar on a pug or king charles spaniel. Every dog however likes reinforcement - and it doesn't have to be food - it can be play, toys, freedom, whatever.

So the bottom line here is if you make mistakes using positive reinforcement methods - you might not have a well trained dog until you sharpen your skills - if you make mistakes using punishment, you might have a highly aggressive dog, or one that shuts down and lives a miserable life of fear and frustration. Or worse case, you don't notice anything is wrong with the dog until he bites your neighbours kid.

Remember the little girl from the video? Well one issue with punishment is the behavior falls apart if the conditions during punishment are no longer present. For example if the trainer is the only person shocking the dog, he may not listen to the little girl unless the trainer is present. In the video the trainer is there filming - so the dog obeys the girl because conditions for punishment in place.

There is no reason to need to resort to punishment unless positive methods have failed, and this will very rarely happen. I would also argue that no matter how well behaved a punishment trained dog is - I would never trust one around my children or loved ones. Punishment can build a ticking time bomb of aggression. People and animals alike who are consistently subjected to punishment will only take so much before they explode. Why even take that risk?

Thursday, September 9, 2010

Find me somebody to love....

Arguably the behavior that seems to drive most people into a frenzy at the dog park (other than a serious fight) is dogs mounting. The most curious thing about this is listening to the aftermath of owners discussing the reasons why this is happening. I'd say the number one thing I hear most is "he/she is being dominant".

I'm going to try not to go into detail about dominance in this post and save that for another time since I want to specifically just discuss mounting - but I'll argue that dominance is usually the number one reason given for mounting.

Go ahead and try to Google 'mounting in dogs' and see what you get. The very first article I see talks about dogs being like wolves, alpha's, and dogs mounting for dominance. Guess that explains why google isn't a good dog trainer and you need to take great care when looking for practical information on the Internet!

I find this topic really interesting because despite the obvious answer to why this behavior occurs, no one seems to want to accept it. So whats mounting then? It's sex. Pure and simple. Rather, its "play" sex. Let me explain

Dogs and all animals come loaded with certain behavior patterns pre-programmed into them. These are referred to as fixed action patterns "FAP's". One good example is a mother dog that bites the umbilical cord of a new born puppy, or puppies that lick the face of their mother to make her regurgitate food. The dogs were never trained to do these things, they are born with the knowledge to help them survive. Usually these fixed patterns have to do with fighting, fleeing, reproducing and eating. When dogs play and get aroused, these patterns come out - dogs will play fight, play chase and yes, play mount.

Ever see a human male get "aroused" and try to "mount" everything he sees in the night club?

Mounting can be a sign of a dog who is unsure or unsocialized. Usually this is because when presented with an unfamiliar situation - the dog gets easily aroused and the FAP's start to show up. While two previous dog friends might have established good rapport to do some play chasing and wrestling - unfamiliar dogs may not engage in that right away, so the mounting FAP shows up instead.

One thing that makes dogs different from wolves is their sexual behavior. In wolves only the 'breeding pair' or what was referred to as alpha male and female would mate. The chief reason for this was to control population to ensure they didn't reproduce more than the food source could handle - however dogs are different.

Dogs don't form packs the way wolves do - dogs in the "wild" form loose social groups that are normally close to human settlements and they live off scraps of food and garbage dumps. Dogs are scavengers and don't hunt big game, so they have no need of packs. As such their sexual behavior is quite promiscuous and will mate with anyone, anywhere. Wolf males are only able to reproduce seasonally, while male dogs are able to reproduce at anytime.

Another difference is the testosterone levels of dogs. An adolescent dog's testosterone levels actually rise above the levels of an adult dog and level off later - so mounting can be much more prevalent during this time.

Another pretty good argument for mounting being sex play is that mounting is greatly reduced after neutering. Mounting may not stop if a dog is neutered later in life and has been play mounting for a while. He's likely to continue the behavior simply because it's been rewarding (Fun) to do in the past.

So what about females? Well one FAP of courtship is to flirt - and one way a female flirts is to quickly mount the male and run off. I'd also argue that mounting in females much more rare than in males.

So what about certain TV personalities arguments that mounting is dominance? Well normally we see mounting behavior follow this pattern -

1) Dog A mounts or starts to mount Dog B
2) Dog B runs away, snaps, growls snarls and dog A gets off
3) Dog A might try again right away or in a few minutes

What should be the reaction if one were trying to establish dominance? Dog A should attack dog B for daring to fight back. However this is very rarely the case and likely has very little to do with his mounting being rejected but rather a response to the aggression of Dog B.

Dominance hierarchies do exist between wolves in captivity in relation to items, however it's normally based on strength - hence when the alpha wolf in captivity is weak or hurt - someone else takes over. It's very common however to see very physically inferior dogs try to mount physically superior dogs, even after being snapped at or growled at as described above.

So when it comes to mounting - the simplest explanation is the correct one. Dogs just get excited and mount sometimes. It's up to us to teach them that mounting isn't an appropriate behavior and to teach them what is. One way to prevent it is to remove your dog from play when he mounts (negative punishment) or to simply tell him to "Sit" if he's well trained.

So remember, if your dog decides to mount you, he's not showing dominance or trying to take over the house - he just really likes you :)