I recently had a debate among some other trainers that are members of our national association here in Canada. I was unaware that so many of them were punishment based trainers and sadly have had to reconsider my membership in the group. I do not want my membership dollars going towards the promotion of using ecollars, prong collars or other such punishment based devices.
One interesting point of argument that many trainers use who employ punishment in their training is that mother dogs use correction and thus punishment and correction are natural and should be part of any training program. Often other dogs are referenced as well, not just the mother, since adult dogs correct other dogs as well.
Let's look at this a little closer:
1) Dog-Dog correction is always expertly timed exactly when the behavior is happening, and it is usually very mild. Mother dogs do not bite their puppies, they often only growl, stare or snap. A physical touch would only happen if these other methods failed, and again it would be very fast and only last fractions of a second. Most other dogs operate in the same manner, a quick growl or snap to get the message across
2) Dog correction is often related to their own well being. Mother dogs will correct a puppy if he bites her too hard while milking, or if fighting with litter-mates. Other dogs usually will correct for things like being humped, continued harassment (to play or otherwise), to guard a resource or to create space and say 'get away from me'.
The key point here is the correction is not designed to compel the other dog into forced action. You do not see other dogs forcing other dogs into heel position, down-stays or loose leash walks. They are not concerned with the other dogs behavior outside of how it relates to them.
This is a key central theme that all people would do well to take note of: Dogs seek to control their own lives, while humans seek to control the dogs.
Another key point of 'correction' is a dog wouldn't correct for natural behaviors. A dog would never 'naturally' be expecting to be corrected for 'normal' behaviors like digging, jumping or chewing objects.
Humans live in a complex world, which dogs do not naturally understand. We need to use our big brains to show them how to live in a modern world, how to not chew our nike shoes and how to cope with being alone for 8 hours. There is nothing natural about the things we ask of the modern dog, so the idea that we can train dogs the same way they train either other is just foolish.
People have been researching dog training for the last 100 years, imagine the strides that have been made in the last 30 years alone. The internet didn't exist 15 years ago, imagine how different the world is in just that brief time. The idea that we haven't found a better way to train our dogs other than watching their mother is pretty insulting to human intelligence.
A blog regarding dog training and behavior, discussing my experiences as I venture through the world of dog training.
Wednesday, August 3, 2011
Mother dog punishment justification
Thursday, July 28, 2011
Management vs Training
I often get asked the question, when my dog is lunging or growling at another dog on a walk - what should I do? My answer is usually the same - get outta there, go home, and call a trainer.
Whenever a dog is in an aroused state of mind, its very difficult to train him or do any proper behavioral correction. A lunging, snarling dog at the end of a leash is not going to be susceptible to any type of behavioral correction that will cure his problem.
Many people will try snapping the leash, grabbing their dog, or even pinning their dog when they get leash reactions like this. None of these things train your dog not to react in that way. Why? Because the behavior is usually being driven by emotion, and you can't punish away emotion.
Imagine I took you up to the top of your home and dangled you off the roof. You are in a huge panic because you feel your life might be in danger. What if I then pull out a gun, point it at you, and demand that you stop panicking and being afraid. Will that work? What will your emotion state be after that happens? If I then take you up to the roof and dangle you off without the gun - will your fear of heights be gone?
This is very similar in dog training. A dog that is being punished via leash corrections, pinning or even shouting isn't having his emotions changed, and thus the behavior will likely not change - or even worse - it might change to something else.
Many dogs that are punished for growling will stop growling - however instead they next time go straight to biting without the warning growl. A leash reactive dog punished in this way, while his behavior may change, could never be trusted off leash as his emotions would still be the same, and out of fear or aggression he may attack.
All proper behavior corrections in dogs take place "sub-threshold". That means when I correct behavior - I never actually want to see the negative behavior again. If your dog growls at other dogs, I want to work with him so that I never see him growl again. This means I always keep him at a level just below his 'threshold' of growling. As we work through behavior modification, we move the dog closer and closer to thing he had the problem with - other dogs etc, all while keeping him under his reactive threshold. The general goal is to usually show and teach the dog other acceptable behaviors he can display, or to relax his fear and show him there is no reason to be afraid.
Using the roof example - a professional therapist would gradually expose you to higher and higher surfaces, ensuring you were OK with one height before moving higher. A professional human therapist would not pull you up to a roof and hold a gun to your head - however in dog training this type of thing seems to happen all the time (Think choke collars and shock collars).
Dogs can learn when they are afraid - but usually not the things we want! Fear is a huge teacher for dogs, but the lesson is usually to 1) Avoid the thing of fear or 2) use aggression to make it go away - neither of which is usually a desirable outcome.
Trying to train when your dog is afraid or in a frenzy just doesn't work.
If you find your dog is reactive on leash, call a (good)trainer and don't keep trying to micromanage the situations - you'll likely make it worse and certainly won't make it better.
Whenever a dog is in an aroused state of mind, its very difficult to train him or do any proper behavioral correction. A lunging, snarling dog at the end of a leash is not going to be susceptible to any type of behavioral correction that will cure his problem.
Many people will try snapping the leash, grabbing their dog, or even pinning their dog when they get leash reactions like this. None of these things train your dog not to react in that way. Why? Because the behavior is usually being driven by emotion, and you can't punish away emotion.
Imagine I took you up to the top of your home and dangled you off the roof. You are in a huge panic because you feel your life might be in danger. What if I then pull out a gun, point it at you, and demand that you stop panicking and being afraid. Will that work? What will your emotion state be after that happens? If I then take you up to the roof and dangle you off without the gun - will your fear of heights be gone?
This is very similar in dog training. A dog that is being punished via leash corrections, pinning or even shouting isn't having his emotions changed, and thus the behavior will likely not change - or even worse - it might change to something else.
Many dogs that are punished for growling will stop growling - however instead they next time go straight to biting without the warning growl. A leash reactive dog punished in this way, while his behavior may change, could never be trusted off leash as his emotions would still be the same, and out of fear or aggression he may attack.
All proper behavior corrections in dogs take place "sub-threshold". That means when I correct behavior - I never actually want to see the negative behavior again. If your dog growls at other dogs, I want to work with him so that I never see him growl again. This means I always keep him at a level just below his 'threshold' of growling. As we work through behavior modification, we move the dog closer and closer to thing he had the problem with - other dogs etc, all while keeping him under his reactive threshold. The general goal is to usually show and teach the dog other acceptable behaviors he can display, or to relax his fear and show him there is no reason to be afraid.
Using the roof example - a professional therapist would gradually expose you to higher and higher surfaces, ensuring you were OK with one height before moving higher. A professional human therapist would not pull you up to a roof and hold a gun to your head - however in dog training this type of thing seems to happen all the time (Think choke collars and shock collars).
Dogs can learn when they are afraid - but usually not the things we want! Fear is a huge teacher for dogs, but the lesson is usually to 1) Avoid the thing of fear or 2) use aggression to make it go away - neither of which is usually a desirable outcome.
Trying to train when your dog is afraid or in a frenzy just doesn't work.
If you find your dog is reactive on leash, call a (good)trainer and don't keep trying to micromanage the situations - you'll likely make it worse and certainly won't make it better.
Labels:
aggression,
clicker training,
punishment
Wednesday, July 13, 2011
Yikes time for an update
Sorry for the lack of updates to my precious 5 followers :) Hopefully there are more people checking out the blog, since I know my site is at least fairly busy.
I've been training full time since June and its been a busy time. I'm changing my store over to provide kong and premier pet products instead of the tuffy / vip toys. Nothing against those toys but they were too expensive to bring in from the USA and my new supplier is in Canada. I hope to have all my products listed in the near future.
I've been taking a few dogs into my home from the SPCA to give them a break from being at the shelter, and to help assess behaviour in the home. I've been lucky to have 2 great dogs come spend some time with me, one of whom went to an excellent home and another who hopefully will soon.
I wanted to share with you all 2 excellent resources regarding punishment, dominance and Cesar Millan. In my travels and classes I actually haven't met that many people that mention him or dominance, however I SEE a lot if it around dog shows, parks etc, so I can only assume the big time Cesar fans out there are not calling positive trainers for help....
Here are two articles that every Cesar Millan fan or hater should read - Thanks to Jean Donaldson for posting them on her facebook
http://www.4pawsu.com/dogpsychology.htm
http://www.4pawsu.com/cesarfans.htm
Cheers,
Tristan
I've been training full time since June and its been a busy time. I'm changing my store over to provide kong and premier pet products instead of the tuffy / vip toys. Nothing against those toys but they were too expensive to bring in from the USA and my new supplier is in Canada. I hope to have all my products listed in the near future.
I've been taking a few dogs into my home from the SPCA to give them a break from being at the shelter, and to help assess behaviour in the home. I've been lucky to have 2 great dogs come spend some time with me, one of whom went to an excellent home and another who hopefully will soon.
I wanted to share with you all 2 excellent resources regarding punishment, dominance and Cesar Millan. In my travels and classes I actually haven't met that many people that mention him or dominance, however I SEE a lot if it around dog shows, parks etc, so I can only assume the big time Cesar fans out there are not calling positive trainers for help....
Here are two articles that every Cesar Millan fan or hater should read - Thanks to Jean Donaldson for posting them on her facebook
http://www.4pawsu.com/dogpsychology.htm
http://www.4pawsu.com/cesarfans.htm
Cheers,
Tristan
Tuesday, May 31, 2011
Email to Kijiji
Hello,
I am a dog trainer in the Halifax area. I'm writing to you concerning a disturbing trend I've seen on your site. There are a large number of ads of peopling seeking to breed their dogs. These ads take the form of either female dog owners looking for studs, or stud dogs looking for females.
I know kijiji is taking steps to try to clean up the ads in the pet section - as noted by your recent change displaying that puppies should not be adopted out until I believe 8 weeks.
I'd ask that you consider adding to your policy to make these types of breeding ads a violation of your policy. The last thing the dog community needs is more backyard breeders and pseudo puppy mills - your site makes it easy for unregulated and unlicensed owners to attempt to become breeders.
I'm curious if this has been considered in anyway and if you have made a decision, or if the decision process is ongoing. I'm sure many others feel this same way and I'd be willing to start a petition or campaign, whatever is required to end this practice.
I am a dog trainer in the Halifax area. I'm writing to you concerning a disturbing trend I've seen on your site. There are a large number of ads of peopling seeking to breed their dogs. These ads take the form of either female dog owners looking for studs, or stud dogs looking for females.
I know kijiji is taking steps to try to clean up the ads in the pet section - as noted by your recent change displaying that puppies should not be adopted out until I believe 8 weeks.
I'd ask that you consider adding to your policy to make these types of breeding ads a violation of your policy. The last thing the dog community needs is more backyard breeders and pseudo puppy mills - your site makes it easy for unregulated and unlicensed owners to attempt to become breeders.
I'm curious if this has been considered in anyway and if you have made a decision, or if the decision process is ongoing. I'm sure many others feel this same way and I'd be willing to start a petition or campaign, whatever is required to end this practice.
Tuesday, May 10, 2011
Breed Specific Law in Yarmouth looking less likely
A Public meeting was held last night to discuss how to change the town of Yarmouths Dog Bylaw in light of a recent Pit bull attack in the area. It looks likely that the "BSL" part of the bylaw that would punish dogs based on breed alone will not go through. There seems to be a very strong, united message from people in and outside the town that this isn't a good solution. I also wrote to the mayor and Council as noted in my below post - and happily all this feedback (including my email) were posted on the Town's website for all to see.
The vanguard newspaper in the area published an article and used some of my comments:
http://www.thevanguard.ca/News/2011-05-09/article-2492483/No-breed-specific-legislation,-council-told/1
The vanguard newspaper in the area published an article and used some of my comments:
http://www.thevanguard.ca/News/2011-05-09/article-2492483/No-breed-specific-legislation,-council-told/1
Monday, April 18, 2011
Open Letter to Mayor and Council of Yarmouth and Premier Dexter and MLA Zack Churchill
from Golden Rule Training
reply-to goldenruletraining@gmail.com
to Mayor.Mooney@townofyarmouth.ca,
DeputyMayor.Boudreau@townofyarmouth.ca,
Councillor.Dares@townofyarmouth.ca,
Councillor.Langille@townofyarmouth.ca,
Councillor.MacIsaac@townofyarmouth.ca,
Councillor.MacKenzie@townofyarmouth.ca,
Councillor.Pink@townofyarmouth.ca
cc ddexter.mla@gmail.com,
churchzj@gov.ns.ca
date Mon, Apr 18, 2011 at 12:31 PM
Good Day Mayor and Councillors, Premier Dexter and MLA Churchill,
I am writing to you regarding the vicious dog attack in the town of Yarmouth. I am a dog trainer based in Dartmouth, Nova Scotia working with many private clients and I also volunteer with the SPCA in dog care and training. I have worked with many pit bull dogs over my years of experience.
I know you are likely receiving a large amount of feedback over this issue so I will try to be brief.
I urge you to reject any legislative change that focus solely on the breed of dog in your by-law. I believe strongly in public safety and certainly in light of the vicious attack that happened in your town, the public expects action to prevent future attacks, but the draft by-law I have seen would not address that issue.
Aggressive dogs are for the most part, are created. Lack of socialization, poor living conditions, cruelty and punishment are what truly cause dog attacks.
In all vicious dog attacks you can usually find one common factor, and its not breed. It's that the dog did not have a high standard of care in the home.
I believe the best solution to this issue is to improve our level of animal education and animal care through-out Yarmouth, but also in all of Nova Scotia.
One of the best groups to deliver this message is the Nova Scotia SPCA, who are mandated to investigate cruelty to animals.
However the provincial government gives only a paltry sum of $3000 dollars to fund their entire cruelty and care organization - an organization whose total costs add up to close to a million dollars.
How can we hope to educate owners and prevent cruelty to animals that result in dog attacks - when the organization mandated for these things isn't funded by our government? In my option, relying on public donations to fund these important initiatives is not responsible governance.
I would ask that the town of Yarmouth, as part of its strategy in dealing with the aftermath of this attack - formally ask the provincial government to significantly increase the SPCA funding for investigating animal cruelty - and to provide education to the general public on the proper care of animals.
Preventing cruelty is the step towards preventing attacks on people. Requiring muzzles and legislating breeds are a piece-meal solution that will not get to the heart of the issue. Imagine how foolish this legislation will look if the next vicious attack comes at the hands of a german shepard, or mastiff, or even a golden retriever. Will we simply add to the breed list as attacks occur?
I would also suggest that instead of requiring breed specific dogs to wear a muzzle - instead order them to take a dog obedience course. I would suggest looking at a dogs ability to cause harm via its size (50lbs + perhaps) for these courses, not breed. Educating people one on one how to control their dog, get attention and obedience, and general animal care would go a long way to improving the living conditions of these dogs and preventing attacks.
I hope you will consider these suggestions in hopes of improving the safety of our citizens, and improving the lives of our canine companions.
Respectfully -
--
Tristan Flynn
www.goldenruletraining.ca
(902)-469-GRDT (4738)
reply-to goldenruletraining@gmail.com
to Mayor.Mooney@townofyarmouth.ca,
DeputyMayor.Boudreau@townofyarmouth.ca,
Councillor.Dares@townofyarmouth.ca,
Councillor.Langille@townofyarmouth.ca,
Councillor.MacIsaac@townofyarmouth.ca,
Councillor.MacKenzie@townofyarmouth.ca,
Councillor.Pink@townofyarmouth.ca
cc ddexter.mla@gmail.com,
churchzj@gov.ns.ca
date Mon, Apr 18, 2011 at 12:31 PM
Good Day Mayor and Councillors, Premier Dexter and MLA Churchill,
I am writing to you regarding the vicious dog attack in the town of Yarmouth. I am a dog trainer based in Dartmouth, Nova Scotia working with many private clients and I also volunteer with the SPCA in dog care and training. I have worked with many pit bull dogs over my years of experience.
I know you are likely receiving a large amount of feedback over this issue so I will try to be brief.
I urge you to reject any legislative change that focus solely on the breed of dog in your by-law. I believe strongly in public safety and certainly in light of the vicious attack that happened in your town, the public expects action to prevent future attacks, but the draft by-law I have seen would not address that issue.
Aggressive dogs are for the most part, are created. Lack of socialization, poor living conditions, cruelty and punishment are what truly cause dog attacks.
In all vicious dog attacks you can usually find one common factor, and its not breed. It's that the dog did not have a high standard of care in the home.
I believe the best solution to this issue is to improve our level of animal education and animal care through-out Yarmouth, but also in all of Nova Scotia.
One of the best groups to deliver this message is the Nova Scotia SPCA, who are mandated to investigate cruelty to animals.
However the provincial government gives only a paltry sum of $3000 dollars to fund their entire cruelty and care organization - an organization whose total costs add up to close to a million dollars.
How can we hope to educate owners and prevent cruelty to animals that result in dog attacks - when the organization mandated for these things isn't funded by our government? In my option, relying on public donations to fund these important initiatives is not responsible governance.
I would ask that the town of Yarmouth, as part of its strategy in dealing with the aftermath of this attack - formally ask the provincial government to significantly increase the SPCA funding for investigating animal cruelty - and to provide education to the general public on the proper care of animals.
Preventing cruelty is the step towards preventing attacks on people. Requiring muzzles and legislating breeds are a piece-meal solution that will not get to the heart of the issue. Imagine how foolish this legislation will look if the next vicious attack comes at the hands of a german shepard, or mastiff, or even a golden retriever. Will we simply add to the breed list as attacks occur?
I would also suggest that instead of requiring breed specific dogs to wear a muzzle - instead order them to take a dog obedience course. I would suggest looking at a dogs ability to cause harm via its size (50lbs + perhaps) for these courses, not breed. Educating people one on one how to control their dog, get attention and obedience, and general animal care would go a long way to improving the living conditions of these dogs and preventing attacks.
I hope you will consider these suggestions in hopes of improving the safety of our citizens, and improving the lives of our canine companions.
Respectfully -
--
Tristan Flynn
www.goldenruletraining.ca
(902)-469-GRDT (4738)
Wednesday, April 6, 2011
One of the most disturbing things I have seen
I came across this story today while browsing - I was surprised I hadn't heard of it before - its about a pitbull dog named Patrick who was thrown down a garbage chute and left to die - he was found as a maintenance man who was about to throw all the garbage in a compacter saw movement in a bag.
WARNING - these images are extremely disturbing and graphic:
http://www.ahscares.org/showarchive.asp?id=772
Amazingly he is still recovering and is inspiring a lot of noise to create new laws and even build new animal care facilities in the state of NJ. If you google Patrick you'll see just how much media attention this is getting. Hopefully he pulls through and finds a nice home, and that his ordeal will create better conditions for thousands of dogs.
All the details and photos of him are available through the above link.
WARNING - these images are extremely disturbing and graphic:
http://www.ahscares.org/showarchive.asp?id=772
Amazingly he is still recovering and is inspiring a lot of noise to create new laws and even build new animal care facilities in the state of NJ. If you google Patrick you'll see just how much media attention this is getting. Hopefully he pulls through and finds a nice home, and that his ordeal will create better conditions for thousands of dogs.
All the details and photos of him are available through the above link.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)